Research? For a research paper???
The sun had come up, the sky was blue with a few light fluffy clouds floating across that open sea. The temperature was close to 60 degrees and rising. In other-words, it was a good morning so to correct that I opened my University e-mail account and found this message:
Mr. Jacks,
I have a few questions about the way that my paper was graded.
-I lost X points for having no citations, but no citations were required so how can I lose points for something that I was not required to have?
-I lost X points for not having a reference page, again not a requirement?
-I lost X points for my intro and conclusion. I am wrong that this is a computer/technology course should my paper be graded more on content than it is on style, grammar, and punctuation?
I am not saying that I deserve a 100 for this paper but does it really only deserve a XX?
I sat there looking at the e-mail wondering, “This student submitted a paper that had a one sentence introduction, no conclusion, and no references.” It had been up to this point that I had assumed that assigning a “Research Paper” would let the students know they were suppose to do research to complete the paper and provide citations and a resource page to these sources.
Maybe it is just me, but every paper I turned in during my college years required that I quote my sources. It was just common sense, you use someone else’s data then you cite that source.
So, I was wrong. Students apparently do not just assume that the paper should have sources and cite them and even worse, some students do not believe they have to write a correctly formed paper. Maybe I am just a bit of a stickler for a paper that reads like a paper and not something that reads like randomly pulling words out of a bag.
This student’s paper would have been scored much high had he simply included an introduction and a conclusion and had spent the time to include his sources. But the good news for him is I am planning to make sure that future students fully understand exactly what is expected… His legacy will live on!
Way to go big guy!

